Cookie Order

After you submit your order, we’ll be in touch verifying your pricing, order pick up and any additional information we may need from you.
Sit tight—we’ll get back to you shortly!
Cookie Order

Traditional Cookies

Almond Joy
A vanilla based cookie with chocolate chips, coconut and almonds…
Birthday Cake
A light vanilla based cookie loaded up with colored sprinkles…
Blue Moon
Our secret recipe that will have your mouth watering just…
Lemon Crinkle Cookie
A delicious Fresh Lemon cookie that is like biting into…
M&M
Vanilla based cooked loaded with m&m’s and rolled in m&m”s…
Molasses Crinkle Cookie
A classic old fashioned cookie filled with a spice of…
Orange Creamsicle Cookie
A old fashioned push pop made into a cookie, a…
Peanut Butter
A Delicious Old fashion Peanut butter cookie loaded with peanut…
Raspberry White Chocolate
A vanilla cookie with dried raspberries and white chocolate chips!
Strawberry Shortcake
A almond based cookie loads up with white chocolate chips…
Vegan Chocolate Chip
A delicious vanilla based cookie, made with vegan butter and…

📝 Please specify your selections and quantities in the text field below.

Gourmet Cookies

Banana Pudding
A banana based cookie topped with a dollop of buttercream…
Cannoli Cookie
A delicious chocolate chip cookie filled with an Italian cannoli…
Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our traditional Chocolate chip cookie with a center filled with…
Cosmic Brownie
A brownie based cookie topped with buttercream, a cosmic brownie…
Nutella Stuffed Cookie
Our chocolate chip cookie recipe filled with a Nutella hazelnut…
Oreo
An Oreo cookie base baked to perfection, topped with buttercream…
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Our famous peanut butter cookie stuffed with strawberry jelly in…
Peanut Butter Cup
Our traditional peanut butter cookie filled with a Reese peanut…
Strawberry and Cream
A strawberry based cookie studded with a strawberry truffle drizzled…
🐢 New! Turtle Cookie
Soft. Gooey. Irresistible. This indulgent cookie is packed with melty chocolate…

📝 Please specify your selections and quantities in the text field below.

What kind of cookies are are you ordering?

Place your order and pay when you pick up. Let us know the date you want to pick up your cookies in the order notes below.

Remember, we are open on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, 9am - 5 pm.

Traditional Cookies → $4/each · $48/dozen

Gourmet Cookies → $5/each · $60/dozen

Please let us know what day you'd like to pick these up. Also, please give us least 48 hours from the time of your order to have them ready for you.
We will be in touch if there are any issues with your pick up day.

Subscribe To The Sweet Spot

Get the inside scoop on sweet new bakes, behind-the-scenes fun, and exclusive goodies—one email a month, no crumbs left behind.
The Sweet Spot